View Messages

Return to Tree Planting

Don't Plant New Tree atop Recently Ground Stump

[Post a Follow Up] [Post to this category]
From: Becky Raimann
City:
Hasitngs, MN
We are going to be removing a maple tree that has died and have the stump removed as well. Can we immediately plant a new tree where the stump was?

 
Extension Message
From: Jay Hayek
Extension Specialist, Forestry
Natural Resources & Environmental Sciences
jhayek@illinois.edu
Greetings Becky:

Short Answer: It is generally "not' recommended to plant a new tree over the top of a recently removed stump. Simply plant the new tree adjacent to the stump, but keep the new planting hole at least three feet away from the stump to allow your new tree ample growing/rooting space (i.e., new trees need adequate mineral soil with good fertility and drainage for proper rooting and water/nutrient uptake).

The reason we generally don't want to plant new trees over the top of existing stumps in yard-like settings is rather simple: the new planting location will have limited mineral soil exposure and inadequate rooting depth for nutrient uptake and structural stability; the sawdust / mulch created from stump grinding has a high carbon to nitrogen (C:N) ratio, thus compromising nitrogen availability for the new tree; and, settling of the newly planted tree within the cavity of the recently ground stump.

Therefore, it is simply easier to find a suitable planting location adjacent to the old stump to accommodate the needs of your newly planted tree. Depending on the size of the stump, it is generally recommended to plant the new tree at least 3 feet away from the old stump.

Best of luck!

 
From: Donald Nealious
City:
Everett, WA
We had a Norway maple (one of three) we planted a few years ago die this year. We would like to replace it with a Cornus kousa 'National' or similar tree.

The maple started to sprout leaves then quit and just died. Would there be a problem with jerking the maple out of the ground and planting the Cornus kousa 'National' in the same hole?

 
Extension Message
From: Jay Hayek
Extension Specialist, Forestry
Natural Resources & Environmental Sciences
jhayek@illinois.edu
That shouldn't be an issue at all since you're "not" technically planting into a wood-encased, excavated stump-hole...

 
[Post a Follow Up] [Post to this category]
 
Return to Illinois Forestry.
Search current board