Extension Educator, Horticulture
Mulching trees isn't particularly new and innovative. Mother Nature has been doing it for years. Most of our landscape trees grow in a forest in their native areas and are naturally mulched by leaf litter and plant debris. The growth and health of landscape trees can be dramatically improved by the proper use of mulches.
Mulches are any materials used on the surface of the soil. This broad definition could include organic materials such as wood chips, pine needles, straw, peat moss, corncobs and lawn clippings. Inorganic mulches would include river rock, ground tires, volcanic rock and synthetic fabrics. However, not all mulches are created equal.
Organic mulches are preferred for plant growth because of their ability to improve soil structure and provide a more natural environment for good root growth and, therefore, good top growth of the plant or tree. Plus mulch prevents collateral damage from the NASCAR lawn mower races or trunk damage caused by the weed whacker wallop.
Rock and stone mulches can cause substantial problems for trees and people according to Bill Vander Weit, City Forester for the City of Champaign. While trees prefer an acidic soil, most rock is alkaline which can lead to micronutrient deficiencies. Rocks also retain heat that can translate into moisture stress for trees. Plus no one likes to hear cries of "Take cover!" as the lawn mower sprays rocks over the landscape.
The presence of rocks also creates difficulties when a tree needs to be removed. Despite the best efforts to remove rocks, the high-speed cutting wheel of a stump grinder can hurl buried rocks long distances. Rock can also become embedded in trees as they grow.
Vander Weit also states that placing rock or stone within the dripline of any tree on City right-of-way (those trees generally between the curb and sidewalk) is prohibited without a permit. Typically the use of rock is only permitted if the tree is surrounded completely by sidewalk, as in downtown or campus plantings.
Unfortunately even organic mulching can be overdone, witnessed by the all too common mulch "volcano" piled around trees. Overmulching results in excessive moisture in the root and trunk areas leading to root or crown rot. Deep mulch can also impede water and air penetration and may create habitat for bark chewing rodents.
Tree Mulching recommendations:
Check out the Landscape Recycling Center at 1210 East University Avenue in Urbana for a variety of mulches. They are having a "buy one get one free" sale now. http://www.city.urbana.il.us/Urbana/main.asp Call 217-344-5323.
International Society of Arboriculture has an excellent brochure, Proper Mulching Techniques as well as lots of information on tree care. Just go to http://www.treesaregood.com or call (217) 355-9411.