This article was originally published on April 14, 2010 and expired on July 31, 2010. It is provided here for archival purposes and may contain dated information.
Most gardeners have heard of heirloom seeds and probably have a fairly good idea what they are. Gardeners often refer to heirloom seeds as "Grandmother's seed" or something similar, said a University of Illinois Extension horticulture educator.
"As the name implies, heirloom seeds are carried down from generation to generation, similar to handing down a desired antique from generation to generation," said Matt Kostelnick. "However, what is so special about this? Isn't that what a seed company can do? In short, yes. But the full answer to this question is a little more complicated."
Gardeners are familiar with "hybrid seed" which is also called "F₁" or "F₁ Hybrid Seed." All are referring to the same thing. Hybrid seed is essentially the opposite of heirloom seed. Hybrid seed is seed that is a cross between two distinctly different parents that have been inbred over numerous generations.
Why do plant breeders inbred? Primarily because they want to be able to produce reliable offspring that contain certain desirable traits. Essentially, the breeders are breeding plants to produce certain desirable characteristics. For example, in large-scale vegetable production, growers prefer hybrid seed because they know the seed is reliable (they will get a uniform crop of vegetables with certain desirable characteristics). Those desirable characteristics might include things like: disease resistance, early fruit development, larger fruits, rounder fruits, and tougher skins on tomatoes for easier harvesting, handling, shipping and longer storage and so on. With flowers, it might include larger flower blooms, "double" blooms, blooms with bright, flashy colors, pizzazz, etc.
"If hybrid seed has all of these desired and dependable characteristics, are there any downsides to hybrid seed," he said. "In other words, what is the advantage to heirloom seed, especially for the home gardener?
"One major disadvantage to hybrid seed is the loss of genetic diversity. When plant breeders develop hybrid seed, many unique genes are lost in the process."
For example, when a tomato breeder is breeding hybrid tomato seeds, many of the unique genetic characteristics (distinct smells, tastes, textures, flavors, colors, shapes, etc.) are lost and do not show up in the hybrid plants. If you've ever eaten sweet corn, tomatoes, peppers, or other crops from "Grandma's" heirloom seed, you might recall very unique tastes, smells, textures, and other qualities not found in hybrid seed. With hybrid seed, where did all those unique characteristics go? They were lost in the breeding process. With heirloom seeds, many of these traits are passed on from generation to generation.
"In fact, many traits that are desirable to the home gardener are weeded out on purpose with hybrid seeds," he explained. "For example, some carrots are bred to be 'super strong.' They are bred to be very tough to allow machines to pull the carrots out of the ground without breaking the carrots. This characteristic makes it easy to harvest carrots by machine but it makes the carrot less enjoyable for the consumer because it's really tough and hard to chew on."
He added that home gardeners have a distinct advantage: they are harvesting carrots by hand in their back yard and therefore do not need a "tough" carrot or a tomato with a tough, thick skin that will ship long distances or last long on the shelf. Many heirloom seeds have the juices, tastes, flavors, textures, smells, and other desirable characteristics found in "Grandma's seed." Home gardeners can take advantage of home gardening and consider the benefits of growing heirloom fruits, vegetables, and flowers.
"Another disadvantage of hybrid seed is that seed collecting from F₁ Hybrid plants is pointless," Kostelnick said. "Why? Without getting into the science and genetics, the offspring from hybrid (F₁) plants is extremely unpredictable and will not produce true-to-type. In other words, the desirable characteristics from the hybrid plants will usually not be present in their offspring.
"Conversely, heirloom seed is obtained from open-pollination and produce seed that is not a clone of the parent plants, but typically looks a lot like the parent. In other words, you can usually collect seeds from heirloom plants (plants grown with heirloom seed) and obtain offspring that resemble the parent plants. During tough economic times like the Great Depression, people relied heavily on collecting their own seed and growing their own food. Passing seed on from generation-to-generation was very common in the past."
Another advantage of heirloom seeds is the maintenance of genetic diversity.
Heirloom seeds pass on many different genes from generation to generation. With hybrid seed, genetic information is "fixed" and only certain genes are preserved with most genetic diversity lost. Heirloom seeds are like genetic diversity banks that maintain many unique genes from generation to generation that are constantly being lost with more and more hybrid plants.
"Heirloom seeds are a major way of preserving genetic diversity, which is a good thing," he said. "By growing heirloom seeds, you're preserving genetic information that is otherwise disappearing for good. Growing heirloom seeds is not only growing, tasting, and enjoying the fruits of flowers of the past; it's also preserving the past.
"A good analogy in comparing hybrid seed with heirloom seed would be eating out at a franchise chain restaurant or at a local, family-owned, non-chain restaurant."
The franchise chain restaurant (which would comparable to the hybrid seed) would have lots of great dishes at a decent price and you could find the same dishes at any of the other chain restaurants. The non-chain, local restaurant would have more uniqueness, more character, less predictability, more charm, and uniqueness in its own special way. If you were looking for something unique and perhaps more "special" you might choose a non-chain, local restaurant.
Are there any disadvantages to heirloom seed for the home gardener? Admittedly, heirloom seed will usually not give the brightest blooms, the most disease resistant vegetables, perfectly round fruits, and many of the flashy bells and whistles seen on hybrid plants. Plants grown from hybrid seed tend to have more vigor, more uniformity, and certain traits that they were bred for. These traits (such as disease resistance, brighter flowers, bigger tomatoes, etc.) are the reasons people by hybrid seed. However, if unique tastes, textures, smells, forms, and other unique traits are more important to you, consider heirloom seeds.
"There are numerous organizations that are dedicated to preserving heirloom seed," said Kostelnick. "The Seed Savers Exchange in Decorah, IA is one of the largest organizations that preserve, collect, grow, and distribute Heirloom Seed. They have their own seed catalog (including an online ordering website) that allows gardeners to obtain heirloom seed.
"There are also many books and other publications that discuss various heirloom seed. Gardeners should definitely take advantage of these exciting opportunities by growing fruits, flowers, and vegetables from seed."
Source: Matthew Kostelnick, Extension Unit Educator, Horticulture, firstname.lastname@example.org
Pull date: July 31, 2010
- Perennial plant of 2017 – Asclepias tuberosa
- Growing asparagus at home
- Soil management may help stabilize maize yield in the face of climate change
- Smaller corn supplies provide opportunity for price rallies
- Join us for Salute to Agriculture Day!
- New fungal leaf disease “tar spot” identified in 3 northern Illinois counties