View Messages

Return to All About Oak

Broken Limb on Oak Tree

[Post a Follow Up] [Post to this category]
From: Marios Zenios
City:
Barrington, IL
We have an oak tree with trunk diameter of about 4 feet. Last night a 25 ft limb snapped. This tree has a couple of squirle holes about 10ft off the ground, right at the break. The exposure shows that the tree has a cavity where the limb broke off. Should our arborist have predicted this and could he have taken preventive measures? We have him inspect all of our trees regularly. He suggested leaving the broken area exposed. Is this the best way to heal the "wound"?

 
Extension Message
From: Jay Hayek
Extension Specialist, Forestry
Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Sciences
jhayek@illinois.edu
Greetings Marios:

Predicting tree failure is nearly impossible - all we can do is use experience and science to reasonably predict when failure is either highly probable, probable, or not probable.

Trees don't heal their wounds, rather they compartmentalize damaged areas via callus tissue or pitch (i.e., phenolics). I personally agree with leaving the "wound" open rather than applying a wound treatment (arbor paint) or other superficial treatments (e.g., cement, foam, sheet-metal, etc.).

Most arborists and foresters agree the best way to handle tree wounds is to simply let the tree take care of the wound naturally. However, that recommendation needs to be made on-site by a professional due to liability concerns.

 
[Post a Follow Up] [Post to this category]
 
Return to Illinois Forestry.
Search current board