Greetings Dawn,
Well, I guess I'm really confused as to "why" your tree company cut the tops off your newly planted white pines?
I agree that no supplemental fertilizers are needed at this time. However, do not spray any "foam stuff" on your trees - this will only interfere with the process of compartmentalizing the wound.
Based on what your telling me, I'm thinking you need to consult a different tree care specialist, preferably someone who is a certified arborist with a horticulture or forestry degree.